 TBD.com
Here’s a question I get asked often by organization managers considering getting more active in social media — Facebook in particular.
One best practice when it comes to Facebook Pages is to set the default setting so that visitors are looking at posts not only by the page owner but also by fans.
But: “What do we do when people start posting a whole bunch of stuff to our Wall?” asks the boss.
Excellent question. By and large, most organizations will get innocuous notes from fans. But for organizations with a cause that some may find controversial, or that are for some other reason possible targets of attention, may attract less desirable kinds of posts. What do you do? Just delete them from the Page? Engage?
New DC-local journalism startup TBD.com (with which the local blog I co-lead, Rockville Central, is associated) is one such organization. It’s a news outlet. People are attracted to it, as a way of promoting their own causes or bringing up their own issues.
TBD.com is committed to engaging with audiences, though — and not hiding behind an organizational wall. How they are handling their Facebook Page is a good case example of a classy move.
Recently, someone who says they are a veteran (I believe it, but can’t verify) left numerous notes and posted document scans about spraying Agent Orange in Guam. It’s a serious issue, but the tone is also more intense than most organizations might want to get behind.
Rather than just delete the posts, TBD.com Page admins wrote this:
Thanks for sharing the docs. We generally only cover local DC/VA/MD area news, but I made sure to copy down all your info here. I’m removing the repeat posts from the page, but keeping record.
Not only is the poster now more likely to be a friend and see TBD.com as honest brokers — so are other people. Here’s a tangible demonstration of the commitment to two-way.
Here it is in situ:
 Click for full size
Well done, guys.
As my readers know, at my recent session at the No Better Time conference on dialogue and deliberation, one of the things I talked about in depth was the local blog I founded over two years ago, Rockville Central. Civic idealist and geek that I am, I created Rockville Central in order to have a sort of “test bed” for a number of the ideas and principles I had been working on for more than a decade in the civic field.
It seems to be filling a need, as this overtly civic online space is the second most-read local blog in the state. This growth has occurred organically, without trying to pump numbers and without hype.
 Rockville Central masthead
(I understand that this blog is a different breed of local blog — that many local blogs are devoted to political argumentation and to snide commentary.)
At the No Better Time conference, some of my colleagues led discussions about the differences between “blogs” and “newspapers.” There were strong views, and a lot of it was expressed in the abstract. This week, two things happened on Rockville Central that illustrate important aspects of what the blog is about. I’ll discuss them in separate posts (today, and tomorrow).
A New Mayoral Candidate
In my town, the incumbent mayor has just announced a first re-election run. There’s a city council member who has been considering running for mayor, too, which is generating a great deal of interest among City Hall watchers. The current mayor announced her re-election campaign on Saturday. I covered it by posting a quick video.
Shortly before that time, I began to get notes from various quarters about the city council member’s plans, cluing me in that she was planning on running. They came from a few independent sources whom I believed to be credible. I had the sense, though, that the council member would rather not have the information get out until they were ready to announce.
Our weekly newspaper comes out on Wednesdays. Today, the paper announced that the city council member had confirmed her mayoral run. They had called the council member on Saturday to get confirmation of the rumor, and ran with it.
I could have done that, but chose not to. I let us get scooped on purpose, and I am proud of it.
Rockville Central is not an in-your-face blog, forcing people to respond to tough questions — it’s a civic space. Sometimes that means conveying news but it does not mean conveying news with a sense of competition behind it. I figured that when the council member was ready to announce (which I expect in a few days) I would cover it the same way I covered the mayoral announcement, offering essentially the same space to each.
What Purpose?
I believe this all is rooted in my sense of purpose in what I do, and it defines the difference between my local civic blogging and Journalism — even though the two may look similar. The difference is this: a journalist sees their role as to inform. I see my purpose as helping the community to be as good as it can be. And that means sometimes I let stories unfold naturally, without help from my own questioning.
This has raised questions among some of my local friends from time to time, when they send me a “scoop” that I then do not run with. It’s all becuase I see my obligations differently. We’ve got a newspaper, and their job is to cover. We’ve also got a local civic blog, and our job is to open up a space for people to enter public life.
Tomorrow, I’ll talk about what it can look like when someone enters that space we’ve opened up.
Boy, I feel for Abigail Pardou. Why? Here’s how Washington Post’s Marc Fisher sets the scene:
As much as any elected official in Washington, Harry “Tommy” Thomas, the D.C. council member from Ward 5, carries himself like a good old-fashioned machine politician. Son of a council member, Thomas is a cheerful and omnipresent face in Northeast, a ward-heeler who prides himself on bringing home the bacon in the form of park facilities, schools and other city projects.
Abigail Padou is the editor and proprietor of Brookland Heartbeat, a bimonthly newsmagazine about the neighborhood near Catholic University. The paper, mailed free to 10,000 registered voters in the area, is a non-profit run entirely by volunteers and supported by a small group of local advertisers.
Last week, for reasons Padou cannot fathom, Thomas posted on his web site a letter to the editor and to all Ward 5 residents accusing the Heartbeat of salacious headlines, biased reporting and a conflict of interest. Thomas was so angry about a story that ran in the paper last July that he demanded a retraction and threatened to go after one of the Heartbeat’s most important advertisers, the Long & Foster realty company. “Long & Foster will be held accountable for its role in underwriting the Brookland Heartbeat,” Thomas wrote, “as well as the businesses that support the publication.”
The article that got Thomas’s goat is a nicely reported, fully sourced, and utterly unsensational story that examines what Ward 5 gets out of Thomas’s position as chairman of the Council’s committee overseeing libraries, parks and recreation. The story’s conclusion: The ward gets very little.
I can relate. To read Fisher’s piece, Thomas is bullying Padou unfairly.
Here in the little town where I live, there are from time to time controversial issues that come up and in my community blog, I try to write about them. I don’t hide my opinions (nor do any other contributors to the blog), but over time as the site has grown people begin to view it much like a newspaper. So I have started to get angry emails (and hear about angry tirades in meetings) about the site’s (and my) supposed bias. These are the same kind of notes that any editor of any newspaper gets, and when I am properly detached I view them as evidence that I am probably on track.
Let me be clear: I never set out to write slanted coverage, and I make a point of trying to lay out my own biases (if any) in any article. This feedback is more a byproduct of the fact that there are controversial issues on which people disagree deeply — not because of anything I have actually done.
But, I am also a neighbor, and so when I am in another frame of mind, such emails can hurt. I don’t have a thick skin.
These kinds of notes can push me to back off, because it feels more trouble than it’s worth to cover some issues. However, I know that I need to lean against that — otherwise the angry cranks become bullies.
Still, sometimes it can be a drag to keep one’s positive attitude. It can be harder than it looks to stay in today’s public square! You become a target.
My friend Adam Pagnucco, who writes a blog on Maryland Politics called, natch, Maryland Politics Watch, had a fascinating post just the other day.
Actually, it wasn’t by him — it was by his wife, Holly Olson. In it, she chronicles the history of her husband’s involvement with MPW and blogging, and announces there are going to be a few changes. Seems the two have a bun in the oven, and Adam’s been asked to scale back a few of his bloggiest traits.
Holly ends the post with this: “[T]his would be a great time for all of you wanna-be bloggers to step up to the plate and start providing guest posts. There are plenty of insightful, witty, and thoughtful readers out there who could offer a post or two a month. So let’s keep MPW alive and active — but let’s do so as a community endeavor. After all, I know that you all will continue to need your political fix — baby or no baby.”
This struck me because in mid-2007 I started a blog about my town called Rockville Central. It’s a sort of civic experiment, trying to open up new spaces for people to communicate on local public issues. It’s been successful (at least along most of the the measurements I care about) but it has fallen short in one aspect: not as many other people have followed suit as I suspected might. There was one other Rockville-based online information source called Rockville Living when I started (a very good site by the way). There are other info sources for the county, and some arts-related things, but not many new sites have cropped up that are just centered on the city.
I think there should be more and I have hoped that folks would emerge with their own blogs, looking at various aspects of what’s going on. But it hasn’t happened to the extent I’d like to see. At least not yet.
Now, to be fair, I have not been explicit about that hope the way Holly is in her post. I will be watching to see how other individuals respond to her call. So far, though, I have seen a small uptick in “outside contributions,” but it doesn’t look like Adam is working any less hard.
Maybe, over at my end, it’s time to start suggesting the idea to certain people directly!
Yesterday two things converged that really got me thinking about localism.
First, I published my analysis of Rockville Central’s reader survey. It was my first chance to see what the readers of my hyperlocal news site really thought about my volunteer work over the last eighteen months or so. It was very gratifying, and at the end I wrote: “[It is] clear that many, many of you who took the time to respond see Rockville Central as ‘yours.’ That means so much and I will always try to respect that.”
Second, I ran across a fascinating tips-from-the-trenches piece on what it’s like to take over and run a local newspaper. This piece included a great sidebar:
You Want To Buy A Weekly?
Find an owner/operator who is retiring. Don’t worry about quality. You can improve the content and revenue yourself.
Financing was tough before the credit crunch, and it’s next to impossible now. So you may have to do an owner-financed deal or pay for this out of your own pocket. The price of a paper depends on its annual revenue, so if you’re looking for a deal, think small and rural.
Pack a lunch. You won’t have the time or the money to eat out for the first few months. (Perhaps years.)
Consider your business skills. You can create great journalism, but do you know how to run a circulation program and print labels? Keep track of ads and expenses? You have to take a hundred bags and bins to the post office — who will do that?
Be humble. Readers don’t care if you won Pulitzer or interviewed governors. They care about their community, whether you make it better and whether you spell their name correctly.
Be true to yourself. This is tough. You’re running a business and you’re a valuable member of the community, but you have to uphold your core values.
All sounds very much like the advice I gave anyone thinking of starting their own community news blog!
It’s all got me thinking: Is it time to develop a real business model for Rockville Central, and embed it even further as a local institution?
|
|
"Hyperlocal" Journalism And Community
Many of my friends and readers of my national commentary know that I am also the founder of a web site called Rockville Central, which is an example of what the Knight Citizen News Network would call “hyperlocal journalism.” Rockville Central is a citizen-produced, all-volunteer local blog that is intentionally designed to embody the kinds of participatory-democratic civic ideas that many of my readers share with me.
I am happy (and proud) to report that the National Civic Review, a well-respected journal on public issues published by the National Civic League, has an article about Rockville Central in the latest (Fall 2008) issue. While copyright restrictions forbid me from making the original available freely, if you simply email me (by responding to this note) I can send you the final draft version without restriction.
I set out with Rockville Central to engage in a kind of civic experiment. I wanted to see what would happen when an online space popped up that had a very particular set of sensibilities. In essence, I wanted to try to embody many of the approaches and ideas espoused by the civic sector.
I learned that, with just a small amount of care, such an enterprise can be successful in a small way. I doubt the ability of something like this to be commercially viable on a large scale. Indeed, insofar as Rockville Central has provided a new space for people, it needs to remain on a human scale; growing too big would kill it.
However, I can honestly say that I hope for the model to proliferate. I’ve pursued Rockville Central specifically with the idea in mind that others could replicate it. Whenever there was a free way to do something, as opposed to an expensive way, I chose the free way.
While it is not necessarily everyone’s cup of tea to be a civic blogger, literally anyone could create something like Rockville Central. There are no special skills required and no training. It does not require access to capital or to fancy foundations.
So, for those who may have had their interest piqued by the story of Rockville Central, I offer this handful of lessons learned. They are things to keep in mind, if you choose to move forward.
ttery, threat, and cajoling.
Come visit Rockville Central! And — more important — if you feel so moved, start something like it yourself in your own community. I would love to hear about it.